
By Carl Delfeld of the Chartwell ETF Advisor
The last few turbulent days for investors in China are a glaring reminder of China’s alphabet market mess. When Chinese investors look to the rumors of government intervention for guidance on when to buy or sell stocks rather than market fundamentals, you know you have a serious problem on your hands.
First, China effectively reversed itself by pulling back a proposal to allow mainland citizens to buy shares in Hong Kong led to a sharp sell off. Second, on PetroChina’s first day of trading yesterday, while its share price almost tripled on the Shanghai exchange, its “H” share equivalent on the Hong Kong exchange fell 8%. The result: PetroChina is trading at 57 times earnings in Shanghai and 22 times earnings in Hong Kong.
Even stranger is that the Communist government for some reason continues to sit on 87% of PetroChina’s shares despite the obvious demand on the part of private investors to pay top dollar. Why not completely privatize PetroChina and use the proceeds to deal with China’s massive environmental challenges.
The recent volatility and confusion on both the Shanghai and Shenzhen markets probably has augmented the role of Hong Kong as the market of choice for global investors and I’ll bet that most Chinese individual investors would prefer to invest through it as well. National pride - this is why China’s leadership pulled the proposal to allow its citizens to invest through Hong Kong.
While the market-oriented British oversaw the Hong Kong market with a light touch, the Chinese Government sees the markets as a means to control money flows. Therefore, they have created a confusing and destabilizing alphabet soup of share classes that thwart market forces because they are not fungible due to China's heavy- handed capital controls.
First are the A-shares listed in Shanghai and Shenzhen which are available to Chinese investors and certain qualified foreign institutional investors. Next are H-shares which are for the Chinese companies listed in Hong Kong. The A-shares are trading at a sharp premium to H-shares. This seems a bit odd considering the 143 mainland companies traded in Hong Kong are generally China's largest and thought to be of the highest quality. Then there are the B-shares which are available to foreign investors and trade in US dollars in Shanghai and in Hong Kong dollars in Shenzhen.
A bit confused? It gets worse when you look at the valuations of individual companies listed in more than one market. The 42 companies actively traded in both the H-share and A-share markets are much more expensive in Shanghai and Shenzhen than in Hong Kong. The 86 companies with both A- and B-shares have the same pattern with, on average, the B-shares much cheaper than their A-share counterparts.
The repercussions of this balkanized share structure will be around for a long time. Chinese investors have jumped into A-share markets with both feet partly because they have precious little other options when it comes to parking their mounting savings. But is their a way for foreign long-term investors to take advantage of the current situation?
While the FTSE/Xinhua 25 ETF (FXI) fell almost 10% yesterday, it is still probably the best way to get at Chinese companies. FXI contains 25 of the largest and most liquid Chinese companies available to international investors and all the shares trade on the Hong Kong Stock Exchange. Eight of the largest ten companies in the index are H-shares and they collectively account for 46% of the index.
If the A-share market in China continues to be volatile and suffers a sharp pullback, I believe the H-share market will weather the storm fairly well because of the valuation gap and the likelihood that global investors will scoop up perceived bargains. If you still are hesitant you might want to hedge a bit by purchasing a put option (right to sell) FXI out as far as January, 2009. I call it China portfolio insurance.
The current market confusion in China is rich in irony. On the tenth anniversary of the turnover of Hong Kong to China rule, the open and free Hong Kong market is showcasing its traditional strengths and free market foundations.
Let the Chartwell ETF Advisor guide you through China's alphabet market mess.